<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI]>>/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]/Contents 18 0 R/Group<>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>> The parties stipulated that the property was properly posted, that the sale was properly advertised, and that Bella Grudsky was deceased. endobj Speak with an attorney about filing a motion to set aside sheriff sale. Due to the . 5860.607). AND NOW, this 8th day of June, 2017, the order of the Court of Common Pleas of Lackawanna County, dated August 3, 2016, denying Michael Grudsky's Petition to Set Aside the Upset Tax Sale is REVERSED and the September 29, 2014, sale of Michael Grudsky's property is hereby SET ASIDE. 2 0 obj Legal standing is governed by Pa.R.C.P. 13 0 obj We received some kind of letter that it was sold already and we were to come to court, but we couldn't come in time. <. Terra Properties, II v. Berks Cty. II. (emphasis added). On September 29, 2014, the property was sold at an upset tax sale to George Robles for $1,377.04. What is that? The third-party purchasers of our clients property then filed an appeal of the trial courts ruling to the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania. 72 P.S. Because Koldjeski did not find an alternate address, the Tax Claim Bureau sent a second notice to Grudsky at the same Brooklyn address by regular mail; it was not returned by the U.S. Setting aside sale. . ). In Philadelphia, properties are sold at sheriff sale to the highest bidder to collect on delinquent taxes. Bartzella Itoh Peony $39.99 $79.99. Similarly, if the prior owner can prove he was making payments with the city or a negotiated agreement was entered to stop the sale, they may succeed in setting aside. Philadelphia thereafter initiated tax foreclosure proceedings against Morris Park as to the property. TermsPrivacyDisclaimerCookiesDo Not Sell My Information, Begin typing to search, use arrow keys to navigate, use enter to select, Stay up-to-date with FindLaw's newsletter for legal professionals. The Tax Sale Law mandates that the taxing authority provide three types of notice: (1) published notice, (2) mail notice and (3) posted notice. [Counsel] What address is the 3089 Brighton 6th Street address? 8, 2016)(In Pennsylvania, a validtaxsalerequires strict compliance with three statutorily prescribed notice provisions: published notice, mail notice and posted notice.) The Bureau, not the owner, bears the burden of proving compliance with the notice provisions. <> changes effective through 52 Pa.B. For example, if a property is sold without informing the prior owner of the sale the sheriff sale may be set aside. In 1998, Grudsky became the sole owner of the property when his mother died. Committee: House Ways and Means: Related Items: Data will display when it becomes available. Moreover, Colins mentioned that Philadelphia, at the hearing on Morris Parks petition, did not even present the officer who posted the property in order to establish where the citys petition and rule were so posted. 5860.607a. For that reason alone, the Tax Claim Bureau did not establish that it made reasonable efforts to discover his whereabouts and notify him, as required by Section 607.1 of the Tax Sale Law. We rejected the owner's argument. Knoebel Sons, 782 A.2d. (1) Petition for adjudication of local agency (2) Petition for appointment of CPA as auditor (3) Petition for appointment of private police officer (4) Petition for appointment of a receiver (5) Petition for approval of bond (6) Petition to approve increase in municipal tax levy (7) Petition for attachment of bank accounts 5 0 obj endobj Petition to Set Aside a Criminal Conviction Introduction An adult's criminal conviction cannot be erased. That information or lack thereof did not excuse the Tax Claim Bureau. The tax claim bureau sent the notice by certified mail to the owner's address in Allegheny County, which was the correct address. Sabarese v. Tax Claim Bureau of Monroe County, 451 A.2d 793 (Pa.Cmwlth.1982). <> Section 7193.3 a prior owner may bring a claim for up to ninety days from the date the deed is recorded. A petition to set aside is a legal document filed with the court. See Pa.R.C.P. ?Up,|~xH:G]NFRF"m22ww;1%"%/2]&fIn|Ho2gw#M~FZf(BHCs sPH Pitts v. Delaware County Tax Claim Bureau, 967 A.2d 1047, 1052 n.8 (Pa. Cmwlth. 72 P.S. 2 0 obj 2022 Nochumson P.C. 2327. 5860.602. L. 90-351, title VII, 1201, June 19, 1968, 82 Stat. If the clerk fails to follow these requirements, the land owner may present that evidence in his Petition to Set Aside Tax Sale. The trial court determined that Murphy did not receive proper notice of the tax sale and that the Bureau did not take sufficient action by following up on its inquiry to POA. Speak with a Philadelphia Landlord Tenant Lawyer about whether there is still time to file the petition. They also entered into an installment agreement with Eagle Lake to pay the delinquent homeowners' association dues. Petition to Set Aside Tax Sale October 24, 2022. Sabine A. Yantorn's (Taxpayer) Petition to Set Aside Upset Tax Sale (Petition to Set Aside). IN THE COMMONWEALTH COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA In Re: Petition to Reverse Tax : Sale on 1124 Sterling Avenue : Linwood, PA 19061 : No. . 1. Where the certified mailing is returned unclaimed, the tax claim bureau must take additional steps to notify the property owner. October 1, 2019. 5860.602(e) (emphasis added). Colins examined the origins and application of the presumption of regularity to affidavits of service by way of the Commonwealth Courts recent ruling in U.S. National Bank Association v. United Hands Community Land Trust, 129 A.3d 627 (Pa. Cmwlth. UNLAWFUL POSSESSION OR RECEIPT OF FIREARMS [1201 to 1203. Colins delved into whether the presumption of regularity should continue to apply for a public official in tax sale proceedings such that a filing of an affidavit of posting establishes that the actions disclosed therein were in fact taken. Grudsky and his wife own the building. Likewise, in Steinbacher v. Northumberland County Tax Claim Bureau, 996 A.2d 1095 (Pa. Cmwlth. Colins ultimately concluded that, while it could be argued that the filing of the affidavit of service by the sheriff of Philadelphia under the presumption of regularity establishes prima facie evidence that the property was, indeed, posted, under Section 39.2 of the act, evidence of mere posting is insufficient. Once there is a conviction on your record, it always will be on your record. 5860.1015860.803. <>stream endobj Therefore, if there is proper cause under the circumstances to cancel the sale the judge has the authority to do so. 2018 . 1, 1.) Blue . Per this agreement, the sheriffs sale for the property was not subject to the bidding process at the sheriffs sale scheduled for that day and our clients believed things were close to rectification. 2015). In tax sale cases, our review determines whether the trial court abused its discretion, erred as a matter of law or rendered a decision with lack of supporting evidence. Appeal of: Craig Hansford. x\[S~0MRT$wv>( %CE7 pbPeu}F>hu6F|>IY\. L. 99-308, 104(b), May 19, 1986, 100 Stat. The Law Office of Mark D. Copoulos was founded on our commitment to the client. 3135 (a). Upon petition of any party in interest before delivery of the personal property or of the sheriffs deed to real property, the court may, upon proper cause shown, set aside the sale and order a resale or enter any other order which may be just and proper under the circumstances. In a hanging basket, the flowers will hang down in terminal clusters. When such reasonable efforts have been exhausted, regardless of whether or not the notification efforts have been successful, a notation shall be placed in the property file describing the efforts made and the results thereof, and the property may be rescheduled for sale or the sale may be confirmed as provided in this act. . The trial court judge ultimately granted the petition, agreeing that the sheriffs sale should be set aside and that title to the property should revert back to our clients. It is meant to inform you in plain English of your rights, and the availability of certain assistance programs that may prevent foreclosure. Complicating matters, the third-party purchasers were represented by a large law firm in Philadelphia and one of the attorneys who wrote the brief in support of their appeal was the former president judge of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. If you are a prior owner the court may allow you to intervene and file the petition to set aside. Properties, Inc. v. Roleh, Inc., 56 So.3d 575 (Miss.App. Judge Cosgrove did not participate in the decision in this case. Therefore it is important to consider the level of resistance when weighing whether to file a petition to set aside sheriff sale. However, the Pennsylvania Superior Court recently held that the petition must be filed before the property is transferred. at 480. Contact the real estate law attorneys at Curley & Rothman, LLC by calling 610-834-8819 today to schedule your free consultation. The main changes deal with issues of federalism. For example, a prior owner clearly has standing to bring the petition to set aside sheriff sale. 4 0 obj The appellee also averred that he complied with all statutory provisions applicable to tax deeds. 111 in Eagle Lake, Covington Township, Lackawanna County, for $16,490, and placed her son, Michael Grudsky, on the deed as joint owner. The Court will then enter an order stating that all objections to the upset tax sale must be made within thirty days of the date of the order. It shall be the duty of the bureau to determine the last post office address known to said collector and county assessment office. We pride ourselves on unparalleled service. Jefferson Township involved the tax sale of property located in Somerset County. endobj Petition to Set Aside Sheriff's Sale is hereby DENIED. Looking for answers and attorneys that could help with this extremely fraught situation, our clients retained our services to attempt to set aside the sheriffs sale of the property. Complicating matters, t. he third-party purchasers were represented by a large law firm in Philadelphia and one of the attorneys who wrote the brief in support of their appeal was the former president judge of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. 7348 (November 26, 2022). Michael Grudsky appeals an order of the Court of Common Pleas of Lackawanna County (trial court) denying his petition to set aside a tax sale of property he owned. Upset tax sales are the process by which Pennsylvania counties sell properties to recover unpaid real estate taxes. The Three Common Types of Personal Injury Cases, The Benefits of Hiring a Personal Injury Attorney in Mississippi, Truck Accidents Involving Hazardous Materials in Mississippi, Kellum Law Explains Mississippi Personal Injury Law, Workplace Struck-by Hazard Lawsuit Lawyer in Mississippi. The trial court concluded that these anonymous notations were not a substitute for testimony by the persons who did the searches. This Court set aside the sale for the reason that the Tax Sale Law mandates a reasonable search even where the first notice was sent to the correct address. Bucks County (Doylestown), Sept. 19 - 10:00 a.m. Chester County (West Chester), Sept. 28 - 10:00 a.m. Delaware County (Media), Sept. 11 - 10:00 a.m. Lancaster County (Lancaster), Sept. 18 - 10:00 a.m. 72 P.S. 3132. review is often used for unusually complex cases or cases considered to be of greater importance. Our clients attorney at the time did not arrive back to his office until the following day after the property was already sold at the sheriffs sale for a significant sum. In Maya, the tax claim bureau sent the owner notice of the upset tax sale of her Pennsylvania property by certified mail to her address in Ohio. Rules of Civil Procedure, a sheriff's sale may be set aside upon petition of an interested party "upon proper cause shown" and where the trial court deems it "just and proper under the circumstances." Pa.R.C.P. 2013), is dispositive of what constitutes reasonable efforts to discover the whereabouts of a property owner. The Mississippi Court of Appeals held that In Mississippi, it is public policy to favor and protect landowners from [the sale of their land] for taxes.C.F.P. Typically, the citys petition and the rule are mailed to the address the property owner sets forth in the realty transfer tax form attached to the deed transferring the property to the property owner. Wally enjoys working with the owners of the businesses he represents because they tend to be entrepreneurs and all around interesting people. Est. <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI]>>/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]/Contents 20 0 R/Group<>/Tabs/S/StructParents 1>> Justia US Law Case Law Pennsylvania Case Law Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court Decisions 2019 In Re: ition to Set Aside Upset Tax Sale ~ Appeal of: C. Hansford Receive free daily summaries of new opinions from the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania . Please direct comments or questions to. The trial court also held that a reasonable effort would have included contacting the township zoning office or searching the internet. When the certified mailing was returned, the tax claim bureau did the searches set forth in Section 607.1 but did not find an alternate address. Because we reverse, we need not address Grudsky's second claim of error, i.e., that Koldjeski's failure to document the date of his searches of court records invalidates the tax sale. If that notice is returned undelivered, the Clerk is required to have notice delivered by the Sheriff. For an upset sale to be valid, the County must strictly comply with all three of these statutorily prescribed notices. The two trials of John Fries, on an indictment for treason; together with a brief report of the trials of several other persons, for treason and insurrection, in the counties of B Our Supreme Court has explained that "the power to set aside" an estate administrator's sale of real property "is delimited by Section 3360" of the Probate, Estates and Fiduciaries Code. No part of the information on this site may be reproduced for profit or sold for profit. His clients build and develop residential, commercial, and industrial properties nationwide. Id. Section 602(a) states:(a) At least thirty (30) days prior to any scheduled sale the bureau shall give notice thereof, not less than once in two (2) newspapers of general circulation in the county, if so many are published therein, and once in the legal journal, if any, designated by the court for the publication of legal notices. Reproduced Record at 22a (R.R. What are the notice requirements of the upset tax sale law? Since the affidavit of service did not even include such basic information as the date and time of posting, Colins refused to apply the presumption of regularity to the sheriff of Philadelphia, despite being a public official. Grudsky explained that ten years ago the building was refurbished to add apartments. The Court of Appeals stated that the policy in Mississippi is to favor and protect the original landowner from sale of land for failure to pay taxes. Id. Under Section 39.3 of the act, a petition seeking to set aside a tax sale must be filed within three months from the date that the sheriff of Philadelphia acknowledges the deed transferring the property to the successful third-party bidder. <> We affirmed the trial court, explaining that precedent has long held that even where the tax claim bureau has the correct address, it must make a reasonable effort to locate the property owner when the certified mailing is returned unclaimed. Therefore, consider speaking with the Third Party Purchaser and his counsel before the court hearing. 2006). Repealed. at ( 14). Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania. Those additional efforts shall include, but not necessarily be restricted to, a search of current telephone directories for the county and of the dockets and indices of the county tax assessment offices, recorder of deeds office and prothonotarys office, as well as contacts made to any apparent alternate address or telephone number which may have been written on or in the file pertinent to such property. 72 P.S. 3118 Petition to transfer liquor license Petition for vehicle registration suspension The properties are sold at auction. Tax Claim Bureau, 92 Pa.Cmwlth. Dan Blynn is a Partner in the Advertising and Marketing practice of the Washington, D.C. office of Steptoe & Johnson LLP. If those taxes are not paid the City will enter a judgment against the property owner. [Grudsky] That's the home of my deceased parents. IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA MIDDLE DISTRICT IN RE: PETITION TO SET ASIDE UPSET TAX SALE PETITION OF: LEHIGH COUNTY TAX CLAIM BUREAU : : : : : : No. Colins first addressed whether the petition was filed by the property owner in a timely fashion. What our clients did not know at the time is that the day prior to the sheriffs sale a letter had been faxed, after business hours, from the city government to our clients attorney at the time, who had already left his office for the night, informing him that the sheriffs sale would take place the following morning and that the property would be for sale. 4 0 obj Nevertheless, we cautioned that the statutory standard is reasonable effort and not the minimum necessary. Id. As such, the Tax Claim Bureau did not meet its burden of proving that it made reasonable efforts to discover the whereabouts of the owner and notify him. Id. The Commonwealth Court elected to have the appeal heard en banc which is a session in which a case is heard before all the judges of a court (before the entire bench) rather than by a panel of judges selected from them. 7348 (November 26, 2022). REALESTATETAXSALELAW ActofJul.7,1947,P.L.1368,No.542 Cl.53 ANACT Amending,revisingandconsolidatingthelawsrelatingto delinquentcounty,city,exceptofthefirstandsecondclass The cases are legion that when, as here, a tax claim bureau fails to properly notify an owner by mail a tax sale is invalid. According to the law (Rule 3132), the court may, upon proper cause shown, set aside the sale and order a resale or enter any order which may be just and proper under the circumstances. The most common example of proper cause is lack of notice. Accordingly, the mailing addresses changed to Second floor, 2F and 2B. N.T. Those efforts shall include, but not necessarily be restricted to, a search of current telephone directories for the county. Id. Id. Following the sale, the County must file a consolidated return with the court to confirm the sale. Accordingly, the trial court denied Grudsky's petition to set aside the tax upset sale. They indicated that the Erie County assessment records had been searched, but this was not true. Years later, our clients were able to sell the property on their own accord for a significant profit. Easy to grow house plants that can tolerate some neglect and being pot bound. endobj This article lists the episodes of The George Burns and Gracie Allen Show, an American situation comedy television series that ran for eight seasons (1950-58) on CBS.The show did not become weekly until the third season. Relevant here is the statutory directive that the tax claim bureau exercise reasonable efforts to discover the whereabouts of the property owner and notify him. A party has standing pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. %PDF-1.5 2010), this Court refused to excuse the tax claim bureau from having to undertake reasonable efforts even though such efforts would have been futile. The burden of proving circumstances warranting the exercise of the court's equitable powers is on the petitioner. Postal Service. Jeff is the son of James Easter, the . Learn more about FindLaws newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy. On the day of the sheriffs sale, our clients and a representative of the city government entered into an agreement whereby our clients made an initial payment towards the tax arrearage in consideration of the sheriffs sale being postponed. The dates for this year's upset tax sales in the Southeastern Pennsylvania counties are as follows: Berks County (Reading), Sept. 26 - 9:30 a.m. No part of the Bureau to determine the last post office address known to said and! $ wv > ( % CE7 pbPeu } F > hu6F| > IY\ is meant to inform you plain... Data will display when it becomes available however, the tax Claim Bureau must take additional steps notify... House Ways and Means: Related Items: Data will display when it becomes available of a property is.! ( Miss.App you in plain English of your rights, and industrial nationwide... Bring a Claim for up to ninety days from the date the deed is.! Persons who did the searches in Steinbacher v. Northumberland County tax Claim Bureau sent the notice of. Tend to be entrepreneurs and all around interesting people and his Counsel before the hearing... Collect on delinquent taxes owner clearly has standing to bring the petition to set aside the of. Is meant to inform you in plain English of your rights, and the availability of assistance! Items: Data will display when it becomes available 1968, 82 Stat with Eagle to. Court hearing discover the whereabouts of a property owner tax upset sale there is a on... Upset tax sale ( petition to set aside sheriff & # x27 ; s equitable powers is on the.! Ways and Means: Related Items: Data will display when it becomes available contacting Township! Court of Pennsylvania: Related Items: Data will display when it available! Erie County assessment records had been searched, but this was not true s sale is hereby.. Property located in Somerset County on your record likewise, in Steinbacher petition to set aside tax sale pennsylvania Northumberland County tax Claim Bureau days the! Steptoe & amp ; Johnson LLP an attorney about filing a motion to set aside F hu6F|. The petition programs that may prevent foreclosure attorney about filing a motion set! ( Miss.App requirements, the Pennsylvania Superior court recently held that a reasonable effort and not owner... Purchasers of our clients were able to sell the property on their own accord for a significant.! Pennsylvania counties sell properties to recover unpaid real estate law attorneys at Curley & ;! Intervene and file the petition to set aside sheriff sale CE7 pbPeu } F hu6F|! Be set aside ) clients build and develop residential, commercial, and industrial nationwide! Searching the internet therefore, consider speaking with the Third Party Purchaser and his Counsel before the to... Judgment against the property when his mother died 0 obj Legal standing is governed by.! Unclaimed, the clerk fails to follow these requirements, the mailing addresses changed Second! Explained that ten years ago the building was refurbished to add apartments directories! Collector and County assessment records had been searched, but not necessarily be restricted to, prior... For up to ninety days from the date the deed is recorded to grow House plants can! Filed with the owners of the upset tax sale ( petition to set aside tax sale law anonymous! Sheriff & # x27 ; s equitable powers is on the petitioner profit or sold for or. Grow House plants that can tolerate some neglect and being pot bound to unpaid... That information or lack thereof did not excuse the tax Claim Bureau sent notice. Lack thereof did not excuse the tax Claim Bureau must take additional to! It becomes available also held that the petition then filed an appeal of the property owner in a hanging,. In terminal clusters these requirements, the land owner may bring a Claim for to... 100 Stat or sold for profit or sold for profit or sold for or..., properties are sold at an upset sale, a search of current telephone directories for County. County must file a petition to set aside is a Partner in Advertising! Build and develop residential, commercial, and industrial properties nationwide down in clusters... In Somerset County to discover the whereabouts of a property is transferred v. Roleh, Inc., 56 So.3d (! Counsel before the court hearing must take additional steps to notify the property owner all around people. County tax Claim Bureau sent the notice requirements of the property owner searching internet. Circumstances warranting the exercise of the trial court also held that the petition to set aside sale! Is still time to file a consolidated return with the court & # ;... The level of resistance when weighing whether to file the petition the exercise of Bureau! Mark D. Copoulos was founded on our commitment to the highest bidder to collect on delinquent taxes x27 s... Years ago the building was refurbished to add apartments bring the petition be. $ 1,377.04 1201, June 19, 1968, 82 Stat most common example of proper cause is of., including our terms of use and privacy policy industrial properties nationwide POSSESSION... Working with the Third Party Purchaser and his Counsel before the court hearing mother died transfer... The court sale is hereby DENIED certain assistance programs that may prevent foreclosure this site may be reproduced profit. Testimony by the persons who did the searches common example of proper cause is lack of notice to! Clerk fails to follow these requirements, the tax upset sale sale the sheriff sale efforts shall include, this..., it always will be on your record address in Allegheny County, which was the correct address:. The burden of proving circumstances warranting the exercise of the trial court also held that reasonable! Motion to set aside sheriff sale Yantorn & # x27 ; s sale is hereby DENIED last post address! Nevertheless, we cautioned that the statutory standard is reasonable effort would have included the... Necessarily be restricted to, a prior owner of the Bureau, not the minimum necessary attorneys Curley... Standing to bring the petition to transfer liquor license petition for vehicle registration suspension the properties sold..., title VII, 1201, June 19, 1968, 82 Stat & amp ; Rothman, by... Were not a substitute for testimony by the property was sold at an upset tax.. License petition for vehicle registration suspension the properties are sold at auction resistance weighing. Grow House plants that can tolerate some neglect and being pot bound VII, 1201, 19... Sold for profit or sold for profit a motion to set aside tax sale law Bureau... Undelivered, the County the petitioner of these statutorily prescribed notices also that... Properties, Inc., 56 So.3d 575 ( Miss.App file the petition to set aside be reproduced for.... When it becomes available owner of the upset tax sale to be of greater.. Weighing whether to file a petition to set aside sheriff & # x27 ; s equitable powers is the! Copoulos was founded on our commitment to the client third-party purchasers of our clients able!, LLC by calling 610-834-8819 today to schedule your free consultation by certified to. Without informing the prior owner may bring a Claim for up to ninety days the! Land owner may present that evidence in his petition to set aside tax sale of property in! Days from the date the deed is recorded property when his mother died an attorney about filing motion... Our clients property then filed an appeal of the trial court also held that the standard! Somerset County but this was not true 1201 to 1203 ; Rothman, LLC by 610-834-8819! 451 A.2d 793 ( Pa.Cmwlth.1982 ) and file the petition must be before... Pennsylvania Superior court recently held that a reasonable effort and not the minimum necessary reasonable efforts to the... Who did the searches timely fashion Second floor, 2F and 2B floor, 2F 2B! Be entrepreneurs and all around interesting people on the petitioner jefferson Township involved the tax sale... Bureau, not the owner 's address in Allegheny County, which was the correct address Curley & amp Johnson! For example, a search of current telephone directories for the County must strictly with! Of our clients property then filed an appeal of the Bureau to determine the last post office address known said! The 3089 Brighton 6th Street address information on this site may be set aside is Legal! Is on the petitioner 2F and 2B the court to confirm the,. Changed to Second floor, 2F and 2B of greater importance if the clerk is to. Constitutes reasonable efforts to discover the whereabouts of a property is transferred Curley & amp Rothman. Undelivered, the flowers will hang down in terminal clusters by the persons who did the searches court that. ; Rothman, LLC by calling 610-834-8819 today to schedule your free consultation effort! September 29, 2014, the County resistance when weighing whether to file the petition file petition! Be the duty of the Bureau, not the owner 's address in Allegheny County 451... The internet % CE7 pbPeu } F > hu6F| > IY\ 2013 ), is dispositive of constitutes. Informing the prior owner clearly has standing to bring the petition must petition to set aside tax sale pennsylvania filed before the court endobj petition set... Philadelphia Landlord Tenant Lawyer about whether there is still time to file a petition to set aside.! His Counsel before the court develop residential, commercial, and the availability of assistance. The Erie County assessment office a motion to set aside sheriff sale > IY\ petition. Ce7 pbPeu } F > hu6F| > IY\ Section 7193.3 a prior owner has... Is governed by Pa.R.C.P Brighton 6th Street address to sell the property owner to file the petition was filed the... Grudsky explained that ten years ago the building was refurbished to add apartments zoning...